Friday, August 17, 2018

2018 PRE-SEASON SIMULATED TEAMS' CONFERENCE END-OF-SEASON STANDINGS AND CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT RESULTS

Below, for each conference, is its teams' simulated final regular season standings and conference tournament results.  Where teams are tied in the regular season standings, I've seeded them into the conference tournament based on their simulated end-of-season ARPI ranks.  Those ranks also determine the outcomes of games decided by Kicks from the Mark.

Please remember that not all conferences play full round robins.  In addition, the simulation takes game locations into account in producing simulated results.  Thus conference tournament outcomes may not necessarily reflect conference standings.  For the conference tournament results, the bold face team is the winner.

Chris Henderson at All White Kit also ranks teams within conferences, using a completely different method that takes many more details about teams into account than my simulation, which is based strictly on teams' historic ARPI ratings.  The average difference between the AWK rankings within conferences and mine is 1.75 positions per team with a median difference of 1 position per team.  Our two systems have roughly 50% of the teams ranked the same or within 1 position of each other.  A key area where we show significant differences is if most of a team's starters from last year are gone, which the AWK system takes into account but my RPI-based simulation doesn't.  A good example of this is High Point, which AWK has at #5 and my simulation has at #1.

ACC REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
ACC1 Duke ACC 26 1
ACC10 Louisville ACC 10 9.5
ACC11 WakeForest ACC 5 11
ACC12 MiamiFL ACC 2 12
ACC13 Syracuse ACC 1 13.5
ACC14 Pittsburgh ACC 1 13.5
ACC2 NorthCarolinaU ACC 24 2
ACC3 FloridaState ACC 22 4
ACC4 NotreDame ACC 22 4
ACC5 Clemson ACC 22 4
ACC6 VirginiaU ACC 21 6
ACC7 NCState ACC 16 7
ACC8 BostonCollege ACC 12 8
ACC9 VirginiaTech ACC 10 9.5

ACC CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

Duke BostonCollege
NorthCarolinaU NCState
FloridaState VirginiaU
NotreDame Clemson

Duke
NotreDame
NorthCarolinaU FloridaState

Duke
NorthCarolinaU
AMERICA EAST REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
AmericaEast1 NewHampshireU AmericaEast 20 1
AmericaEast2 StonyBrook AmericaEast 17 2
AmericaEast3 Hartford AmericaEast 16 3
AmericaEast4 VermontU AmericaEast 10 4.5
AmericaEast5 Binghamton AmericaEast 10 4.5
AmericaEast6 Albany AmericaEast 9 6
AmericaEast7 UMassLowell AmericaEast 6 7
AmericaEast8 UMBC AmericaEast 5 8
AmericaEast9 MaineU AmericaEast 2 9

AMERICA EAST CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

Hartford Albany
VermontU Binghamton

StonyBrook
Hartford
NewHampshireU VermontU

NewHampshireU
StonyBrook

AMERICAN REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
American1 UCF American 23 1.5
American10 Temple American 1 10
American2 SouthFlorida American 23 1.5
American3 ConnecticutU American 21 3
American4 Cincinnati American 17 4
American5 Memphis American 14 5
American6 SMU American 13 6
American7 Tulsa American 5 7.5
American8 Houston American 5 7.5
American9 EastCarolina American 4 9

AMERICAN CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

ConnecticutU SMU
Cincinnati Memphis

SouthFlorida
ConnecticutU
UCF Cincinnati

UCF
ConnecticutU

ATLANTIC SUN REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
AtlanticSun1 FloridaGulfCoast AtlanticSun 24 1
AtlanticSun2 Lipscomb AtlanticSun 21 2
AtlanticSun3 Liberty AtlanticSun 18 3
AtlanticSun4 Stetson AtlanticSun 15 4
AtlanticSun5 KennesawState AtlanticSun 8 5
AtlanticSun6 NorthFlorida AtlanticSun 6 6.5
AtlanticSun7 NorthAlabama AtlanticSun 6 6.5
AtlanticSun8 NJIT AtlanticSun 2 8.5
AtlanticSun9 JacksonvilleU AtlanticSun 2 8.5

ATLANTIC SUN CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

Liberty NorthFlorida
Stetson KennesawState

Lipscomb
Liberty
FloridaGulfCoast Stetson

FloridaGulfCoast
Lipscomb
ATLANTIC TEN REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
AtlanticTen1 StJosephs AtlanticTen 30 1
AtlanticTen10 MassachusettsU AtlanticTen 7 10
AtlanticTen11 RhodeIslandU AtlanticTen 5 11.5
AtlanticTen12 Richmond AtlanticTen 5 11.5
AtlanticTen13 Davidson AtlanticTen 1 13
AtlanticTen14 StBonaventure AtlanticTen 0 14
AtlanticTen2 StLouis AtlanticTen 27 2
AtlanticTen3 GeorgeWashington AtlanticTen 22 3
AtlanticTen4 LaSalle AtlanticTen 21 4
AtlanticTen5 VCU AtlanticTen 19 5.5
AtlanticTen6 Duquesne AtlanticTen 19 5.5
AtlanticTen7 GeorgeMason AtlanticTen 17 7
AtlanticTen8 Fordham AtlanticTen 16 8
AtlanticTen9 Dayton AtlanticTen 10 9

ATLANTIC TEN CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

StJosephs Fordham
StLouis GeorgeMason
GeorgeWashington Duquesne
LaSalle VCU

StJosephs
LaSalle
StLouis GeorgeWashington

StJosephs
StLouis

BIG EAST REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
BigEast1 Georgetown BigEast 27 1
BigEast10 SetonHall BigEast 0 10
BigEast2 Marquette BigEast 22 2
BigEast3 Butler BigEast 17 3.5
BigEast4 DePaul BigEast 17 3.5
BigEast5 Providence BigEast 14 5
BigEast6 StJohns BigEast 13 6
BigEast7 Xavier BigEast 8 7
BigEast8 Creighton BigEast 5 8
BigEast9 Villanova BigEast 4 9

BIG EAST CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

Butler StJohns
DePaul Providence

Georgetown
DePaul
Marquette Butler

Georgetown
Marquette
BIG SKY REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
BigSky1 EasternWashington BigSky 25 1.5
BigSky10 IdahoState BigSky 0 10
BigSky2 MontanaU BigSky 25 1.5
BigSky3 NorthernColorado BigSky 21 3
BigSky4 IdahoU BigSky 16 4
BigSky5 NorthernArizona BigSky 14 5
BigSky6 SacramentoState BigSky 10 6
BigSky7 WeberState BigSky 8 7
BigSky8 PortlandState BigSky 5 8.5
BigSky9 SouthernUtah BigSky 5 8.5
BIG SKY CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

NorthernColorado SacramentoState
IdahoU NorthernArizona

EasternWashington
IdahoU
MontanaU NorthernColorado

EasternWashington
MontanaU
BIG SOUTH REGULAR SEASON

BigSouth1 HighPoint BigSouth 30 1 10
BigSouth10 USCUpstate BigSouth 5 10 1
BigSouth11 Hampton BigSouth 0 11 0
BigSouth2 Longwood BigSouth 23 2.5 7
BigSouth3 Campbell BigSouth 23 2.5 7
BigSouth4 Radford BigSouth 19 4 5
BigSouth5 GardnerWebb BigSouth 15 5.5 4
BigSouth6 UNCAsheville BigSouth 15 5.5 4
BigSouth7 CharlestonSouthern BigSouth 9 7 2
BigSouth8 Winthrop BigSouth 7 8 1
BigSouth9 Presbyterian BigSouth 6 9 1
 BIG SOUTH CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

HighPoint Winthrop
Longwood CharlestonSouthern
Campbell UNCAsheville
Radford GardnerWebb

HighPoint
Radford
Longwood Campbell

HighPoint
Campbell
BIG TEN REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
BigTen1 Rutgers BigTen 31 1
BigTen10 Purdue BigTen 6 10.5
BigTen11 IowaU BigTen 6 10.5
BigTen12 MichiganState BigTen 5 12
BigTen13 IllinoisU BigTen 1 13.5
BigTen14 MarylandU BigTen 1 13.5
BigTen2 PennState BigTen 29 2
BigTen3 OhioState BigTen 23 3
BigTen4 NorthwesternU BigTen 22 4.5
BigTen5 NebraskaU BigTen 22 4.5
BigTen6 MinnesotaU BigTen 21 6
BigTen7 WisconsinU BigTen 19 7
BigTen8 MichiganU BigTen 16 8
BigTen9 IndianaU BigTen 12 9
BIG TEN CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

Rutgers MichiganU
PennState WisconsinU
OhioState MinnesotaU
NorthwesternU NebraskaU

Rutgers
NorthwesternU
PennState MinnesotaU

Rutgers
PennState
BIG TWELVE REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
BigTwelve1 WestVirginiaU BigTwelve 27 1
BigTwelve10 KansasState BigTwelve 0 10
BigTwelve2 TexasU BigTwelve 16 2.5
BigTwelve3 KansasU BigTwelve 16 2.5
BigTwelve4 TexasTech BigTwelve 14 4
BigTwelve5 TCU BigTwelve 12 5
BigTwelve6 OklahomaState BigTwelve 11 6
BigTwelve7 Baylor BigTwelve 10 7.5
BigTwelve8 OklahomaU BigTwelve 10 7.5
BigTwelve9 IowaState BigTwelve 3 9
BIG TWELVE CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

WestVirginiaU OklahomaU
TexasU Baylor
KansasU OklahomaState
TexasTech TCU

WestVirginiaU
TCU
TexasU KansasU

WestVirginiaU
TexasU
BIG WEST REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
BigWest1 LongBeachState BigWest 22 1
BigWest2 CalStateFullerton BigWest 18 2
BigWest3 CalStateNorthridge BigWest 15 3
BigWest4 UCSantaBarbara BigWest 13 4
BigWest5 UCIrvine BigWest 10 5
BigWest6 UCRiverside BigWest 5 6.5
BigWest7 CalPoly BigWest 5 6.5
BigWest8 UCDavis BigWest 3 8.5
BigWest9 HawaiiU BigWest 3 8.5
 BIG WEST CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

LongBeachState UCSantaBarbara
CalStateFullerton CalStateNorthridge

LongBeachState
CalStateFullerton
COLONIAL REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
Colonial1 Northeastern Colonial 25 1
Colonial10 Towson Colonial 2 10
Colonial2 Hofstra Colonial 23 2
Colonial3 Drexel Colonial 20 3
Colonial4 William&Mary Colonial 15 4
Colonial5 UNCWilmington Colonial 14 5
Colonial6 JamesMadison Colonial 9 6
Colonial7 DelawareU Colonial 8 7
Colonial8 Elon Colonial 5 8
Colonial9 CollegeofCharleston Colonial 3 9
COLONIAL CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

Drexel JamesMadison
William&Mary UNCWilmington

Northeastern
UNCWilmington
Hofstra Drexel

Northeastern
Hofstra
CONFERENCE USA REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
ConferenceUSA1 Rice ConferenceUSA 28 1.5
ConferenceUSA10 Marshall ConferenceUSA 7 10.5
ConferenceUSA11 MiddleTennessee ConferenceUSA 7 10.5
ConferenceUSA12 UAB ConferenceUSA 4 12
ConferenceUSA13 UTSA ConferenceUSA 0 13.5
ConferenceUSA14 FIU ConferenceUSA 0 13.5
ConferenceUSA2 NorthTexas ConferenceUSA 28 1.5
ConferenceUSA3 Charlotte ConferenceUSA 25 3
ConferenceUSA4 LouisianaTech ConferenceUSA 23 4
ConferenceUSA5 OldDominion ConferenceUSA 21 5
ConferenceUSA6 FloridaAtlantic ConferenceUSA 20 6
ConferenceUSA7 WesternKentucky ConferenceUSA 15 7
ConferenceUSA8 UTEP ConferenceUSA 14 8
ConferenceUSA9 SouthernMississippi ConferenceUSA 9 9
CONFERENCE USA CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

Rice UTEP
NorthTexas WesternKentucky
Charlotte FloridaAtlantic
LouisianaTech OldDominion

Rice
Charlotte
NorthTexas OldDominion

Rice
NorthTexas
HORIZON REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
Horizon1 NorthernKentucky Horizon 27 1
Horizon10 YoungstownState Horizon 1 9.5
Horizon2 Milwaukee Horizon 22 2
Horizon3 IUPUI Horizon 20 3
Horizon4 WrightState Horizon 17 4
Horizon5 IllinoisChicago Horizon 11 5
Horizon6 ClevelandState Horizon 10 6
Horizon7 Oakland Horizon 9 7
Horizon8 Detroit Horizon 8 8
Horizon9 GreenBay Horizon 1 9.5
HORIZON CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

IUPUI ClevelandState
WrightState IllinoisChicago

NorthernKentucky
WrightState
Milwaukee IUPUI

NorthernKentucky
Milwaukee
IVY REGULAR SEASON (NO CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT)

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
Ivy1 Princeton Ivy 21 1
Ivy2 Harvard Ivy 16 2.5
Ivy3 Brown Ivy 16 2.5
Ivy4 Columbia Ivy 8 4
Ivy5 Yale Ivy 6 5
Ivy6 Dartmouth Ivy 5 6
Ivy7 Cornell Ivy 3 7
Ivy8 PennsylvaniaU Ivy 2 8
METRO ATLANTIC REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
MetroAtlantic1 Monmouth MetroAtlantic 30 1
MetroAtlantic10 Iona MetroAtlantic 3 10
MetroAtlantic11 StPeters MetroAtlantic 0 11
MetroAtlantic2 Manhattan MetroAtlantic 21 3
MetroAtlantic3 Rider MetroAtlantic 21 3
MetroAtlantic4 Quinnipiac MetroAtlantic 21 3
MetroAtlantic5 Siena MetroAtlantic 19 5
MetroAtlantic6 Marist MetroAtlantic 14 6
MetroAtlantic7 Niagara MetroAtlantic 9 7
MetroAtlantic8 Fairfield MetroAtlantic 8 8.5
MetroAtlantic9 Canisius MetroAtlantic 8 8.5
METRO ATLANTIC CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

Marist StPeters
Niagara Iona
Fairfield Canisius

Monmouth
Fairfield
Manhattan Niagara
Rider Marist
Quinnipiac Siena

Monmouth
Siena
Manhattan Rider

Monmouth
Rider
MID AMERICAN REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
MidAmerican1 KentState MidAmerican 33 1
MidAmerican10 NorthernIllinois MidAmerican 7 9.5
MidAmerican11 OhioU MidAmerican 5 11
MidAmerican12 Akron MidAmerican 0 12
MidAmerican2 BallState MidAmerican 30 2
MidAmerican3 Buffalo MidAmerican 25 3
MidAmerican4 WesternMichigan MidAmerican 21 4
MidAmerican5 BowlingGreen MidAmerican 15 5.5
MidAmerican6 CentralMichigan MidAmerican 15 5.5
MidAmerican7 Toledo MidAmerican 14 7
MidAmerican8 EasternMichigan MidAmerican 12 8
MidAmerican9 MiamiOH MidAmerican 7 9.5
MID AMERICAN CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

KentState EasternMichigan
BallState Toledo
Buffalo CentralMichigan
WesternMichigan BowlingGreen

KentState
WesternMichigan
BallState Buffalo

KentState
BallState
MISSOURI VALLEY REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
MissouriValley1 Drake MissouriValley 21 1
MissouriValley2 IllinoisState MissouriValley 16 2
MissouriValley3 Valparaiso MissouriValley 11 3
MissouriValley4 MissouriState MissouriValley 9 4
MissouriValley5 LoyolaChicago MissouriValley 7 5
MissouriValley6 UNI MissouriValley 5 6
MissouriValley7 IndianaState MissouriValley 3 7
MissouriValley8 Evansville MissouriValley 2 8
MISSOURI VALLEY CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

Valparaiso UNI
MissouriState LoyolaChicago

Drake
LoyolaChicago
IllinoisState Valparaiso

Drake
IllinoisState
MOUNTAIN WEST REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
MountainWest1 SanJoseState MountainWest 29 1.5
MountainWest10 AirForce MountainWest 7 9.5
MountainWest11 ColoradoState MountainWest 5 11
MountainWest12 NevadaU MountainWest 0 12
MountainWest2 SanDiegoState MountainWest 29 1.5
MountainWest3 UNLV MountainWest 27 3
MountainWest4 UtahState MountainWest 19 4
MountainWest5 NewMexicoU MountainWest 16 5
MountainWest6 WyomingU MountainWest 15 6
MountainWest7 BoiseState MountainWest 14 7
MountainWest8 FresnoState MountainWest 12 8
MountainWest9 ColoradoCollege MountainWest 7 9.5
MOUNTAIN WEST CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

UNLV WyomingU
UtahState NewMexicoU

SanJoseState
UtahState
SanDiegoState UNLV

SanJoseState
UNLV

NORTHEAST REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
Northeast1 FairleighDickinson Northeast 22 1
Northeast2 CentralConnecticut Northeast 20 2
Northeast3 StFrancis Northeast 17 3
Northeast4 Bryant Northeast 14 4
Northeast5 SacredHeart Northeast 13 5
Northeast6 RobertMorris Northeast 9 6
Northeast7 MountStMary Northeast 2 8
Northeast8 Wagner Northeast 2 8
Northeast9 LongIsland Northeast 2 8

NORTHEAST CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

FairleighDickinson Bryant
CentralConnecticut StFrancis

FairleighDickinson
StFrancis

OHIO VALLEY REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
OhioValley1 MurrayState OhioValley 30 1
OhioValley10 TennesseeMartin OhioValley 4 10
OhioValley11 EasternIllinois OhioValley 0 11
OhioValley2 TennesseeTech OhioValley 23 2
OhioValley3 EasternKentucky OhioValley 19 3
OhioValley4 Belmont OhioValley 18 4
OhioValley5 AustinPeay OhioValley 17 5
OhioValley6 SoutheastMissouriState OhioValley 16 6
OhioValley7 SIUEdwardsville OhioValley 12 7
OhioValley8 JacksonvilleState OhioValley 8 8
OhioValley9 Morehead OhioValley 5 9

OHIO VALLEY CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

AustinPeay JacksonvilleState
SoutheastMissouriState SIUEdwardsville

Belmont
AustinPeay
EasternKentucky SoutheastMissouriState

MurrayState
Belmont
TennesseeTech EasternKentucky

MurrayState
TennesseeTech

PAC TWELVE REGULAR SEASON (NO CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT)

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
PacTwelve1 Stanford PacTwelve 33 1
PacTwelve10 OregonU PacTwelve 4 10
PacTwelve11 ArizonaState PacTwelve 2 11
PacTwelve12 OregonState PacTwelve 1 12
PacTwelve2 UCLA PacTwelve 28 2
PacTwelve3 SouthernCalifornia PacTwelve 26 3
PacTwelve4 ArizonaU PacTwelve 22 4
PacTwelve5 CaliforniaU PacTwelve 21 5
PacTwelve6 ColoradoU PacTwelve 16 6
PacTwelve7 WashingtonState PacTwelve 15 7
PacTwelve8 UtahU PacTwelve 13 8
PacTwelve9 WashingtonU PacTwelve 9 9

PATRIOT REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
Patriot1 Bucknell Patriot 27 1
Patriot10 American Patriot 1 10
Patriot2 Navy Patriot 22 2
Patriot3 BostonU Patriot 20 3
Patriot4 Colgate Patriot 19 4
Patriot5 Lehigh Patriot 15 5
Patriot6 Lafayette Patriot 12 6
Patriot7 HolyCross Patriot 7 7
Patriot8 Army Patriot 5 8
Patriot9 LoyolaMD Patriot 2 9

PATRIOT CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

BostonU Lafayette
Colgate Lehigh

Bucknell
Colgate
Navy BostonU

Bucknell
BostonU

SEC REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
SEC1 SouthCarolinaU SEC 30 1
SEC10 MissouriU SEC 9 9.5
SEC11 LSU SEC 4 11
SEC12 KentuckyU SEC 3 12
SEC13 MississippiState SEC 2 13
SEC14 GeorgiaU SEC 0 14
SEC2 FloridaU SEC 27 2
SEC3 Auburn SEC 23 3.5
SEC4 TexasA&M SEC 23 3.5
SEC5 ArkansasU SEC 21 5
SEC6 TennesseeU SEC 19 6
SEC7 Vanderbilt SEC 14 7
SEC8 MississippiU SEC 12 8
SEC9 AlabamaU SEC 9 9.5

SEC CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

MississippiU AlabamaU
Vanderbilt MissouriU

SouthCarolinaU
MississippiU
FloridaU Vanderbilt
Auburn TennesseeU
TexasA&M ArkansasU

SouthCarolinaU
TexasA&M
FloridaU Auburn

SouthCarolinaU
FloridaU
SOUTHERN REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
Southern1 Samford Southern 25 1
Southern10 Citadel Southern 0 10
Southern2 Furman Southern 23 2
Southern3 UNCGreensboro Southern 16 3
Southern4 WesternCarolina Southern 15 5
Southern5 Mercer Southern 15 5
Southern6 EastTennesseeState Southern 15 5
Southern7 Chattanooga Southern 7 7.5
Southern8 VMI Southern 7 7.5
Southern9 Wofford Southern 3 9
SOUTHERN CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

VMI Wofford
Chattanooga Citadel

Samford
VMI
Furman Chattanooga
UNCGreensboro EastTennesseeState
WesternCarolina Mercer

Samford
WesternCarolina
Furman UNCGreensboro

Samford
Furman
SOUTHLAND REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
Southland1 StephenFAustin Southland 29 1.5
Southland10 NichollsState Southland 4 10.5
Southland11 SELouisiana Southland 4 10.5
Southland12 IncarnateWord Southland 2 12
Southland2 CentralArkansas Southland 29 1.5
Southland3 HoustonBaptist Southland 25 3
Southland4 AbileneChristian Southland 22 4
Southland5 McNeeseState Southland 21 5
Southland6 Lamar Southland 20 6
Southland7 TexasCorpusChristi Southland 11 7
Southland8 NorthwesternState Southland 10 8
Southland9 SamHoustonState Southland 6 9
SOUTHLAND CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

StephenFAustin NorthwesternState
CentralArkansas TexasCorpusChristi
HoustonBaptist Lamar
AbileneChristian McNeeseState

StephenFAustin
AbileneChristian
CentralArkansas HoustonBaptist

StephenFAustin
CentralArkansas
SOUTHWESTERN REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
Southwestern1 AlabamaState Southwestern 26 2
Southwestern10 AlcornState Southwestern 3 10
Southwestern11 AlabamaA&M Southwestern 1 11
Southwestern2 Howard Southwestern 26 2
Southwestern3 TexasSouthern Southwestern 26 2
Southwestern4 MississippiValley Southwestern 19 4
Southwestern5 PrairieViewA&M Southwestern 14 5
Southwestern6 ArkansasPineBluff Southwestern 13 6
Southwestern7 Grambling Southwestern 12 7
Southwestern8 JacksonState Southwestern 7 8
Southwestern9 SouthernU Southwestern 5 9

SOUTHWESTERN CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

AlabamaState JacksonState
Howard Grambling
TexasSouthern ArkansasPineBluff
MississippiValley PrairieViewA&M

AlabamaState
MississippiValley
Howard TexasSouthern

AlabamaState
Howard

SUMMIT REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
Summit1 SouthDakotaState Summit 24 1
Summit2 NorthDakotaState Summit 19 2
Summit3 OralRoberts Summit 17 3
Summit4 Denver Summit 16 4
Summit5 UNOmaha Summit 12 5
Summit6 SouthDakotaU Summit 7 6.5
Summit7 NorthDakotaU Summit 7 6.5
Summit8 WesternIllinois Summit 1 8.5
Summit9 IPFW Summit 1 8.5

SUMMIT CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

SouthDakotaState Denver
NorthDakotaState OralRoberts

SouthDakotaState
OralRoberts

SUN BELT REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
SunBelt1 SouthAlabama SunBelt 30 1
SunBelt10 LouisianaLafayette SunBelt 3 10
SunBelt11 GeorgiaState SunBelt 3 10
SunBelt2 UALR SunBelt 23 2.5
SunBelt3 CoastalCarolina SunBelt 23 2.5
SunBelt4 Troy SunBelt 18 4
SunBelt5 AppalachianState SunBelt 16 5
SunBelt6 ArkansasState SunBelt 14 6
SunBelt7 TexasState SunBelt 9 7
SunBelt8 GeorgiaSouthern SunBelt 8 8
SunBelt9 LouisianaMonroe SunBelt 3 10

SUN BELT CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

SouthAlabama GeorgiaSouthern
UALR TexasState
CoastalCarolina ArkansasState
Troy AppalachianState

SouthAlabama
AppalachianState
UALR CoastalCarolina

SouthAlabama
CoastalCarolina

WAC REGULAR SEASON

Regular Season Standing for Seeding Purposes Team for Standings Conference for Standings Regular Season Points Regular Season Standing
WAC1 Seattle WAC 22 1
WAC2 UtahValley WAC 20 2
WAC3 UMKC WAC 19 3
WAC4 TexasRGV WAC 11 4.5
WAC5 GrandCanyon WAC 11 4.5
WAC6 CalStateBakersfield WAC 9 6
WAC7 CaliforniaBaptist WAC 7 7
WAC8 NewMexicoState WAC 3 8
WAC9 ChicagoState WAC 0 9

WAC CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT

UMKC CalStateBakersfield
TexasRGV GrandCanyon

Seattle
TexasRGV
UtahValley UMKC

Seattle
UMKC

WEST COAST REGULAR SEASON (NO CONFERENCE TOURNAMENT)

WestCoast1 Pepperdine WestCoast 25 1
WestCoast10 Pacific WestCoast 0 8
WestCoast2 SantaClara WestCoast 21 2
WestCoast3 BYU WestCoast 20 3.5
WestCoast4 LoyolaMarymount WestCoast 20 3.5
WestCoast5 SanDiegoU WestCoast 15 5
WestCoast6 SanFrancisco WestCoast 12 6
WestCoast7 Gonzaga WestCoast 9 7
WestCoast8 PortlandU WestCoast 4 7.5
WestCoast9 StMarys WestCoast 4 7.5

2018 SEASON SIMULATION END-OF-SEASON NCAA TOURNAMENT BRACKET

Below is my pre-season simulated NCAA Tournament bracket based on the simulation's final RPI ratings and ranks and other data relevant to the Women's Soccer Committee.  The simulation is based on the Committee's decision-making patterns over the last 11 years as applied to the simulated end-of-season data (including from conference tournaments).

As I mentioned in the post with the simulated end-of-season ratings, the RPI tends, on average, to underrate teams from stronger conferences and overrate ones from weaker conferences.  The simulation nevertheless determines game results based on the assumption that teams will perform in accord with their ratings, as adjusted for home field advantage.  What this means is that the simulation likewise tends to underrate teams from stronger conferences and overrate teams from weaker ones.  And, this carries over into the simulated NCAA Tournament bracket, so that this pre-season simulated bracket no doubt has some teams in it from mid-major conferences that ultimately won't be there and has left out some teams from strong conferences that ultimately will be there.  As I make weekly substitutions of actual game results for simulated results, this problem will decrease.  By the end of the season, the problem will be gone altogether.

All White Kit's Chris Henderson likewise has produced an NCAA Tournament bracket, using a completely different approach that takes into account significant items of current information.  His bracket and my simulated bracket agree on 40 of the 64 teams.  Most of the teams on which they don't agree have to do with differences in who the automatic qualifiers are from mid-major and lesser conferences.  Among the teams that are significant "players" in the competition to get a bracket position, he has the following teams in the bracket that my simulation doesn't:  Memphis (as an Automatic Qualifier), Louisville, Baylor, Butler (as an AQ), Michigan, Wisconsin, Colorado, Utah, Washington State, and Loyola Marymount.  My simulation has the following teams that he doesn't:  Connecticut, Kansas, Arizona, Cincinnati, Minnesota, Marquette, Harvard, North Texas, and Drexel.  Of my simulation's teams, Harvard, North Texas, and Drexel are examples of ones that may occupy their current positions in the simulation due to the RPI's underrating/overrating problem.

Here are the 64 teams the simulation puts into the bracket, plus the teams from the simulation's top 60 that it doesn't put into the bracket.  The NCAA Seed or Selection column's codes are:

1 = 1 seed
2 = 2 seed
3 = 3 seed
4 = 4 seed
5 = unseeded at large selection
6 = unseeded Automatic Qualifier
7 = top 60 team not getting an at large selection
8 = top 60 team not eligible due to record below 0.500

NCAA Seed or Selection Automatic Qualifier ARPI Rank for Formation Team for Formation
1 AQ 2 Stanford
1 0 4 UCLA
1 AQ 3 WestVirginiaU
1 AQ 5 SouthCarolinaU
2 0 7 FloridaU
2 AQ 10 NorthCarolinaU
2 AQ 1 Princeton
2 AQ 6 Rutgers
3 0 11 SouthernCalifornia
3 0 13 Duke
3 0 18 PennState
3 0 9 Auburn
4 AQ 12 Georgetown
4 0 8 FloridaState
4 0 15 TexasA&M
4 0 16 VirginiaU
5 0 14 NotreDame
5 0 19 CaliforniaU
5 0 21 ArkansasU
5 0 20 ArizonaU
5 0 22 TexasU
5 0 38 Clemson
5 0 26 SouthFlorida
5 0 28 Northeastern
5 0 25 ConnecticutU
5 0 31 KansasU
5 0 36 SantaClara
5 0 41 NorthwesternU
5 0 32 Cincinnati
5 0 40 MinnesotaU
5 0 35 Marquette
5 0 37 TCU
5 0 42 Harvard
5 0 50 NorthTexas
5 0 44 MississippiU
5 0 47 TennesseeU
5 0 46 Drexel
5 0 48 OhioState
5 0 51 TexasTech
5 0 45 NCState
6 AQ 17 UCF
6 AQ 30 MurrayState
6 AQ 23 Hofstra
6 AQ 29 SouthAlabama
6 AQ 33 Pepperdine
6 AQ 24 StJosephs
6 AQ 27 Rice
6 AQ 34 Bucknell
6 AQ 39 LongBeachState
6 AQ 43 KentState
6 AQ 49 FloridaGulfCoast
6 AQ 56 Monmouth
6 AQ 58 HighPoint
6 AQ 54 Samford
6 AQ 53 EasternWashington
6 AQ 55 UNLV
6 AQ 75 StephenFAustin
6 AQ 76 Drake
6 AQ 89 NewHampshireU
6 AQ 99 NorthernKentucky
6 AQ 119 FairleighDickinson
6 AQ 127 Seattle
6 AQ 144 AlabamaState
6 AQ 160 SouthDakotaState
7 0 52 WashingtonState
7 0 59 SanJoseState
7 0 60 Lipscomb
8 0 57 MississippiState

Monday, January 8, 2018

NCAA TOURNAMENT BRACKETOLOGY: WHAT MATTERS MOST TO THE COMMITTEE? POST 2017 UPDATE

What factors have the most influence on the Women's Soccer Committee's decisions on NCAA Tournament seeds and at large selections?  That's the subject of this post.

Each year, I review the Committee's decisions in comparison to 13 basic factors I've drawn from the at large decision-making rules the Committee must follow.  And, I review the decisions in comparison to 78 additional factors, each of which pairs two of the 13 basic factors weighted at 50% each.  I review the Committee's decisions for each of  #1 seeds, #2 seeds, #3 seeds, #4 seeds, all 16 seeded teams as a single group, and at large selections.

I then combine the data from all the years in my data base and, looking at the Top 60 teams, identify "yes" and "no" standards for each factor, for each decision group.  Using the Adjusted RPI Rank factor and the #1 seed group as an example,  "yes" a team with an ARPI Rank of #1 always has received a #1 seed; and "no" a team with an ARPI rank of #8 or poorer never has received a #1 seed.

I've just updated the standards after adding the 2017 data and Committee decisions to the data base.  And, I've done a review to see which factors appear to have been the most powerful in the Committee's decision process.

But first, for context, here's a table that summarizes how well the factor standards match with the Committee's decisions over the last 11 years:






















For each year, the "... Final +/0 and 0/0" column shows the number of positions in each group that the standards "fill" with no decision required.  The "Percent Filled by Standards" row shows the percent of available positions the standards fill for each group.  The "Undecided Positions to Fill per Year" column shows, for an average year, the number of positions in each group that the standards by themselves cannot fill, in other words the remaining openings.  And, the "Candidates for Undecided Positions" column shows the number of candidates per year the standards identify for the remaining openings.  All of these candidates meet no "yes" and no "no" standards for the group.  (All other teams are excluded because they meet no "yes" standards and 1 or more "no" standards.)

As the table shows, the standards do a great job with the #1 seeds and a good job with the #2 seeds.  They do lesser jobs with the #3 and #4 seeds, but when looking at all the seeds as a single group, the standards again do a good job.  This suggests that the Committee is pretty consistent in its selection of seeds as a whole but is less consistent in how it assigns teams #9 through #16 between the #3 and #4 seed groups.  In addition, for each position the standards by themselves cannot fill, the standards identify roughly 2 candidates for the position.

For at large selections, combining both the at large seeded and at large unseeded teams, the standards by themselves fill 87.8% of the available positions.  Each year, there are about 4 positions the standards by themselves cannot fill.  And there are 6 to 7 candidates to fill those positions.

The bottom line is that the standards do a good job of reflecting how the Committee makes its decisions.

With that in mind, which standards are the most powerful?  To evaluate that, for each factor and decision group, looking at the Top 60 teams, I count the number of teams that meet "yes" and "no" standards -- the teams for which those particular standards make a decision.  And, I count the number of teams that meet neither a "yes" nor a "no" standard -- the teams for which those particular standards don't make a decision.  Once I've done that, I look to see which standards account for the most "yes" decisions, the most "no" decisions, and the fewest "don't make a decision" -- the fewer teams in the "don't make a decision" group, the more powerful the factor.

Here are the factors that produce the most "yes" decisions, the most "no" decisions, and the fewest "don't make a decision," for each decision group.  Where I list two factors together, I'm referring to paired individual factors with each weighted 50%:

#1 Yes:  ARPI Rank and Top 60 Common Opponents Rank
#1 No:  ARPI Rank
#1 Don't make a decision:  ARPI Rank and Top 60 Common Opponents Rank

#2 Yes:  ARPI and Top 60 Common Opponents Score
#2 No:  ARPI Rank and Top 60 Common Opponents Rank
#2 Don't make a decision:  ARPI Rank and Top 60 Common Opponents Rank

#3 Yes:  ARPI Rank and Conference Rank
#3 No:  ARPI and Top 50 Results Rank
#3 Don't make a decision:  ARPI and Top 60 Common Opponents Rank

#4 Yes: ARPI and Top 60 Common Opponents Score
#4 No:  ARPI and Top 60 Common Opponents Rank
#4 Don't make a decision:  ARPI and Top 60 Common Opponents Rank

At Large Yes:  ARPI and Top 50 Results Rank
At Large No:  ARPI Rank and Top 50 Results Score
At Large Don't make a decision:  ARPI and Top 50 Results Rank

Here are some observations:

First, looking at at large selections and seeds together, the Adjusted RPI has the most powerful influence.  This is consistent with past observations.  Essentially, the Committee starts with the ARPI and then looks to see how other factors suggest a change from the ARPI rankings.

Second, for at large selections, Top 50 Results (Score or Rank) combined with the ARPI has the most powerful influence.  This is consistent with past observations.  Top 50 Results Score looks at good results (wins or ties) against Top 50 teams, and assigns values to those results based on the ranks of the opponents and the game locations.  The higher ranked the Top 50 opponent, the higher the score assigned for a good result, with the assigned scores very much higher for very highly ranked opponents than for lower ranked opponents.

Third, for seeds, Top 60 Common Opponents results (Score or Rank) combined with the ARPI has the most powerful influence.  This confirms, quite clearly, past observations.  Top 60 Common Opponents results is based on the requirement that the Committee consider results against common opponents in making at large selections.  Essentially, this is a mini-rating system for only the Top 60 teams based on common opponent results.  For each Top 60 team, it looks at its results as compared to the results of each other Top 60 team for opponents the two teams had in common.  Then, it assigns a score and ranking to each Top 60 team based on its cumulative common opponent comparisons with the other Top 60 teams.

Fourth, for #3 seeds, teams' Conference Ranks come into play.  This confirms something I've suggested previously, which is that in distinguishing among teams ranked #9 through #16, where making distinctions is difficult, the Committee tends to defer to teams from stronger conferences.

Fifth, teams' Non-Conference RPIs (Ratings and Ranks), Head to Head results against Top 60 opponents, and poor results, although they have some influence, have limited influence as compared to the other factors.

All of these observations are consistent with past observations, so the Committee did not do anything radically different in 2017.


HOW MANY TOP 60 OPPONENTS SHOULD WE SCHEDULE, FOR NCAA TOURNAMENT PURPOSES? POST-2017 UPDATE

Last year, I published information on the number of Top 60 opponents that the NCAA Tournament #1, #2, #3, and #4 seeds played and that the unseeded teams that did and did not get at large selections played.  That information was based on 10 years' data, from 2007 through 2016.  I've added the data from the 2017 season, so here is a table with updated numbers:


And below are charts showing a little more detail (but not the Average and Median numbers) for the #1, #2, #3, and #4 seeds and for the unseeded teams that did (yes) and did not (no) get at large selections: