This will be the first in a series of articles analyzing the NCAA Women's Soccer Committee's decisions in forming this year's NCAA Tournament bracket. I'm starting with the #1 seed decisions, as the #1 seeds provide a good and relatively simple platform for explaining how I do this kind of analysis. Later in this article, I'll provide a link to detailed explanation of the data and tools underlying my analyses, which is at the RPI for Division I Women's Soccer website. I won't repeat the link in the subsequent articles.
Now and then in this series of articles, I'll refer to the Committee's historic patterns. By that, I mean its patterns since 2007, which is as far back as my data base goes.
Historically, #1 seeds have gone only to teams within the Top 7 of the NCAA RPI rankings. My system produces the following table for this year's Top 7:
To start, I'll explain what the two yellow highlighted columns refer to:
One of the factors the Women's Soccer Committee considers is teams' NCAA RPI ranks. Using NCAA RPI ranks as an example:
Historically, the team with the #1 NCAA RPI rank always has gotten a #1 seed. Teams with NCAA RPI ranks of #8 and poorer never have gotten #1 seeds. This lets me create two standards, which you can think of as a "Yes" standard and a "No" standard. If a team meets the NCAA RPI rank Yes standard, it means that teams meeting that standard always have gotten a #1 seed so that if the Committee is being consistent with its historic patterns, that team will get a #1 seed. The converse is true for a team meeting a No standard, it won't get a #1 seed. Thus for the NCAA RPI rank factor, the standards for a #1 seed are:
Yes: <2
No: >7
Based on the factors the NCAA requires the Women's Soccer Committee to consider, I have created a list of 15 "single" factors (of which NCAA RPI rank is one), each of which has a scoring system. I also have paired each factor with each other factor to create a list of 103 additional "paired" factors, to create a total of 118 factors. Within a paired factor, each individual factor is weighted at 50% to produce a scoring system for that paired factor.
As is the case for the NCAA RPI rank factor, for each of the other single and paired factors, there is a Yes standard and a No standard based on the Committee's historic patterns. Every decision the Committee has made historically has been consistent with all of the factor standards. I keep things this way by updating the standards every year to accomodate any differences for the year between the standards and the Committee's decisions.
For a very detailed explanation of this system, you can go here: NCAA Tournament: Predicting the Bracket, At Large Selections and Seeds.
Looking at the above table and using North Carolina as an example, you can see that this year it meets 32 Yes standards for a #1 seed and 0 No standards. This means that based on past history, it should get a #1 seed. Vanderbilt, Wake Forest, and Michigan State are similar examples of teams that, based on past history, should get #1 seeds.
In the table, however, Ohio State is an interesting case. It meets 7 Yes standards but also 1 No standard. What this means is that Ohio State has an historically unique profile, one the Committee has not seen before. Since Ohio State meets only 1 No standard and got a #1 seed, two important questions are: What was the No standard and how did Ohio State's standard score relate to that standard? Is the Committee's decision to give it a #1 seed a significant deviation from the Committee' historic patterns?
The No standard Ohio State meets is for the Top 50 Results Score and Conference RPI paired factor. Its No standard is <31,570.97. Ohio State's score for that factor is 31,214.60, which is why it received a No. Since the Committee gave Ohio State a #1 seed, this means that for this standard going forward, I will have to adjust it to <31,214.60.
An important question is: How significant is the difference between the current No standard and Ohio State's score? Historically, there have been 126 teams in the NCAA RPI rank 1 to 7 range. Of these, only 3 were in the range between the current No standard and Ohio State's score:
2009 Notre Dame met 0 Yes and 15 No standards for a #1 seed
2010 Florida met 0 Yes and 2 No
2025 Kansas met 0 Yes and 40 No
These numbers show that none of these teams' score on this factor was necessary to its not receiving a #1 seed. Even if the new No standard had been in effect, each team still would have been in the No #1 seed category. That being the case, I cannot say that the No score change I will have to make is significant. And, I cannot say Ohio State's getting a #1 seed is a significant change from the Committee's historic patterns.
In that light, Ohio State's getting a #1 seed and Wake Forest not getting one seems like a reasonable Committee close call and I cannot say it is a signifcant change from the Committee's historic patterns, if Wake Forest not getting a #1 seed is not a significant change. This also explains why Ohio State is at the bottom left of the NCAA Tournament bracket in the #1.4 seed position and Wake Forest, just having missed a #1 seed, is the #2 seed in the same quadrant as Ohio State in the #2.1 seed position.
Looking at Wake Forest, it met 6 Yes standards for a #1 seed. Since it did not get a #1 seed, this means that going forward I will need to adjust each of those standards. Here is information on those standards and the significance of the adjustments I will need to make to accomodate Wake's not getting a #1 seed:
NCAA RPI rank and Non-Conference RPI rank paired factor standard of >345.5. Wake's score is 346.5. Historically, 2 #1 seeded teams received a Yes score based on this factor, that would not have received it with the standard adjusted as required by Wake's not getting a #1 seed:
2022 UCLA met 13 Yes and 0 No standards for a #1 seed
2023 BYU met 2 Yes and 0 No standards
As the Yes numbers show, both of those teams would have received #1 seeds regardless of the standard for this factor. Thus I cannot say the required standard change from >345.5 to >346.5, to accommodate Wake's not getting a #1 seed, is significant.
NCAA RPI rank and Conference rank paired factor standard of >344.95, Wake's score is 345.42. Historically, no team received a Yes score for this factor that would not have received it with the standard adjusted as required by Wake's not getting a #1 seed, so I cannot say the required standard change is significant.
NCAA RPI rank and Top 60 Common Opponents score paired factor standard of >178.30. Wake's score is 179.44. Historically, 2 #1 seeded teams received a Yes score for this factor, that would not have received it with the standard adjusted as required by Wake's not getting a #1 seed:
2021 Florida State met 13 Yes and 0 No standards for a #1 seed
2025 Vanderbilt met 1 Yes and 0 No standards for a #1 seed. At first glance, it might seem like Vanderbilt needed a Yes for this factor to get its #1 seed. However, that is not the case. In 2025, three other teams met some Yes standards and 0 No standards and clearly were #1 seeds. Other than Vanderbilt, all the other candidates met 0 Yes standards and at least 1 No standard and thus clearly were not #1 seeds. If disregarding this factor, that would have left only Vanderbilt as a candidate, meeting 0 Yes and 0 No standards and therefore getting the remaining #1 seed by default. In this light, I cannot say the required standard change from >178.30 to >179.44 is significant.
NCAA RPI rank and Poor Results rank paired factor standard of >347.50. Wake's score is 349.02. Historically, 4 #1 seeded teams received a Yes score for this factor, that would not have received it with the standard adjusted as required by Wake's not getting a #1 seed:
2023 Florida State met 26 Yes and 0 No standards for a #1 seed
2023 UCLA met 7 Yes and 0 No standards
2025 Stanford met 29 Yes and 0 No standards
2025 Virginia met 16 Yes and 0 No standards
As the Yes numbers show, all of those teams would have received #1 seeds regardless of the standard for this factor. Thus I cannot say the required standard change from >347.50 to >349.02, to accommodate Wake's not getting a #1 seed, is significant.
NonConference RPI rank and Poor Results rank paired factor standard of >346.97. Wake's score is 348.5. Historically, 2 #1 seeded teams received a Yes score for this factor, that would not have received it with the standard adjusted as required by Wake's not getting a #1 seed:
2022 UCLA met 13 Yes and 0 No standards for a #1 seed
2023 Florida State met 26 Yes and 0 No standards
As the Yes numbers show, both of those teams would have received #1 seeds regardless of the standard for this factor. Thus I cannot say the required standard change from >346.97 to >348.5, to accommodate Wake's not getting a #1 seed, is significant.
Conference rank and Poor Results rank paired factor standard of >334.53, Wake's score is 336.49. Historically, no teams received a Yes score for this factor that would not have received it with the standard adjusted as required by Wake's not getting a #1 seed, so I cannot say the required standard change is significant.
In summary, there is no basis in the Committee's historic patterns for saying the changes to the Yes standards required by Wake not getting a #1 seed are significant. By extension, there is no basis for saying Wake's not getting a #1 seed is a significant change from the Committee's historic patterns.
Finally, based on the above table, with there already clearly being 4 #1 seeds, Baylor meeting 0 Yes and 0 No standards should not get a #1 seed (although it might under other circumstances) and Notre Dame meeting 0 Yes and 11 No standards should not get a #1 seed.
Altogether, there is no basis for saying the Committee's #1 seed decisions are inconsistent with its historic patterns.
NOTE: You may have noticed my repeated use of "there is no basis for saying ...." It is possible that the Committee, on occasion in the past, considered and assigned value to the factors I've discussed similar to the values assigned by the standards, and considered those values important in making its decision. It that happened, however, it is not possible to know it from the data, since there are other standards that independently explain every Committee decision. Thus I cannot say for sure that the standard changes required by the Committee's decisions this year are insignificant, but I can say that there is no basis in the data for saying they are significant.

























